Skip to Main Content

Photo Albums

Back to Photo Albums

30th Moot Court Competition

Now in its 30th year, the Wabash College Moot Court competition brings Wabash men together through the support of the Wabash Club of Indianapolis and the Rhetoric Department. The competiton gives students the chance to be a lawyer for a day, arguing a case in front of an appellate court panel of judges who advance participants based on the strength of their arguments within the law. Mentorship and judging in the preliminary rounds is provided by a host of Wabash alumni and friends with a wealth of experience within the law.

a group of people in black robes

The 2023 Moot Court participants inlcuded advocates (back row, from left) Seth Kirkpatrick '24, Gabriel Pirtle '25, Liam Grennon '24, and Andrew Dever '25; and judges (front row, from left) Hon. Darren Chadd '92, Hon. Dana Kenworthy, Hon. Damon Leichty '94, and Matt Carlson, associate professor of philosophy.

a man holding a microphone and holding a book

Jeff Drury, associate professor of rhetoric, introduces the advocates to the Salter Hall audience.

a man in a suit holding a microphone and paper

Scott Himsel, associate professor of political science and Wabash's pre-law advisor, introduces the judges.

two men sitting at a table

The case being argued involves the First Amendment and social media platforms and the constitutioinality of state laws that regulate how social media platforms handle users' posts. Kirkpatrick (left) and Pirtle were counsel for the Petitioners.

a man standing at a podium

Kirkpatrick was first to argue. He is a senior rhetoric and political science major from South Bend, Indiana.

a man in a suit standing at a podium with a microphone

Kirkpatrick is also Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of the Wabash Student Senate.

a group of men in black robes

Dr. Carlson asled questions early.

a group of men sitting at a table

Grennon (left) and Dever were counsel for the Respondents.

a group of people in a courtroom

Judges Chadd (right) and Kenworthy listen to a point while Carlson checks his notes.

a man sitting at a table with a sign

Pirtle listens as Kirkpatrick takes his turn at the podium.

a group of men sitting at a table

Grennon and Dever were active listeners.

a man standing at a podium

Kirkpatrick is a Senior Fellow with the Wabash Democracy and Public Discourse initiative.

a group of people sitting at a table

Judge Leichty, a judge on the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Indiana, asks a question.

a man sitting at a table

Kirkpatrick surveys the stage as Pirtle approcahes the podium.

a man standing at a podium with a microphone

Pirtle is a PPE major from Sullivan, Indiana.

two men sitting at a table

The respondents react to a point from Pirtle.

a man standing at a podium

Pirtle is a member of the Pre-Law Society with plans of law school following graduation.

a man standing at a podium

Pirtle his fellow Moot Court finalists were arguing a case that will appear in front of the U.S. Supreme Court in the Spring.

a man standing at a podium with a microphone

Plenty in the petitioners' case was reflected in the state's decision to treat social media platforms as "common carriers."

a group of people sitting at a table

This panel of judges can be intimidating to face.

a group of people sitting at a table with signs

Each of these three judges graduated from Indiana high schools. Chadd (left) was elected judge of the Montgomery County Circuit Court in 2022, while Kenworthy has ben a judge on the Indiana Court of Appeals since 2022.

a man in a suit and tie

Pirtle argued for a law that allowed for content moderation provisions.

a group of men sitting in chairs

Students in attendance were interested in the arguments presented.

a man standing at a podium with a microphone

Dever was first up for the respondents, representing social media companies.

a group of men sitting at a table

Both Kirkpatrick and Pirtle took notes intently.

a man standing at a podium with a microphone

Dever is a history and Spanish major from Dallas, Texas.

a man standing at a podium

Dever is a member of the soccer team, The Bachelor, and the Wabash Democracy and Public Discourse initiative.

a man in a suit standing at a podium with a microphone

The judges praised Dever's courtroom demeanor.

a man standing at a podium with a microphone

Following the competition, Dever was named the Floyd Artful Advocacy Prize, which honors the memory of Hamilton County lawyer Douglas B. Floyd. The winner is not only a successful advocate, but aslo kind, tactful, and principled.

a man sitting at a table with a microphone

Grennon listens to a question from the judges before approaching the podium.

a man standing at a podium with microphones

Grennon is an English major from Concord, New Hampshire.

a man standing at a podium speaking into a microphone

He is the Student Body Treasurer, an enrollment ambassador, a writing center consultant, a member of the tennis team, and a tutor to the First Plus scholars.

a man standing at a podium with a microphone

The respondents claimed that current legislation was violating free speech rights.

a group of people sitting at a table

Judge Leichty raises another question.

two men sitting at a table

Pirtle confers with Kirkpatrick on one of Grennon's points.

a man speaking into a microphone

Grennon faced more than a few questions from the judging panel.

a group of people sitting in a row

There were plenty of interested audience members in Salter Hall.

a man standing at a podium

Kirkpatrick handled the rebuttal for the Peitioners.

a couple of men sitting at a table

Not every mement of Moot Court is an intense one.

a man sitting in a room

There were plenty of debates in the audience as the judges made their final decisions.

two men sitting at a table

Pirtle applauds (right) as Kirkpatrick is announced as the winner.

a man shaking hands with another man in a courtroom

Kirkpatrick (left) accepts his Top Advocate award from Dr. Carlson.

a group of men in suits

Dever (center) receives tthe Floyd Artful Advocacy Prize from Drs. Drury (left) and Himsel.

a group of people posing for a photo

A group photo featuring the evening's judges, finalists, and all participatnts in the 2023 Moot Court in attendance.

a group of people in black robes

Top Advocate Kirkpatrick (center) with the judges.

Download Album Photos