| Reviewer | Institution |
| Robert W. Aaron | Indiana University |
| Stephen Ball | Cleary University |
| Lisa Barley | Cleary University |
| Glenda Droogsma-Musoba | Indiana Project for Academic Success |
| Mark Engberg | University of Michigan |
| Bill Gardner | Cleveland State University |
| Debra Gentry | Center of Inquiry in the Liberal Arts |
| Pat Helland | Vanderbilt University |
| Carol Himelhoch | Cleary University |
| Marie Kendall Brown | University of Michigan |
| Tom Nelson Laird | National Survey of Student Engagement |
| Nathan Lindsay | University of Michigan |
| Megan Moore Gardner | John Carroll University |
| Amelia Nöel-Elkins | Indiana University |
| John Pryor | Dartmouth College |
| Chris Rasmussen | University of Michigan |
| Leslie Robinson | Indiana University |
| Tricia Seifert | University of Iowa |
| Ada Simmons | Indiana University |
| JoNes VanHecke | University of Michigan |